Several years ago I approached the City of Auburn requesting they open the Office of Assigned Counsel (OAC) Public Defenders contract to bid.

The rate then paid to the OAC was approximately $22,000.00 per month. I advised the City I could bid it at $20,000 plus provide additional attorneys. The City declined and renewed with the current firm first for $24,000, then again for $26,000 a month. That exercise cost the City approximately $240,000 in additional OAC compensation over my offer.

Months ago I approached the City again and was told the City is considering bringing the position in-house. I recently read that employee benefits equal approximately 30 percent of wages. Further, the City’s stated requirements to be a public defender are overly strenuous, probably more for liability sake then to protect the accused. So we can expect those “exceptionally qualified” employees to be paid an additional premium.

I encourage the City to continue looking at efficiencies. I request that they begin by looking at their own practices. While we all want the best money can buy, sometimes the best we can afford is a better deal.

Having been a pro tem judge for the cities of Tacoma and Auburn, I have presided over thousands of cases, set bail, issued warrants, imposed sentences and sanctions, and dismissed cases. I do not take the OAC responsibilities lightly.

I ask the City of Auburn to please consider opening the OAC contract for bid, but make the requirements such that zealous advocates are encouraged to apply. I believe the City leaders can find adequate public defenders for less than the current annual $312,000.

– John Torres, attorney at law